2. The Things You Can't Quite See
One of the most effective tricks in horror is to keep the monster hidden.
You hear it breathing. You catch a glimpse of movement. You see something disappear behind a doorway.
Then the camera turns, and there's nothing there.
VHS naturally lends itself to this kind of uncertainty. Its softer image and limited detail can make dark areas harder to interpret, especially when the original footage is poorly lit.
A shadow becomes difficult to distinguish from a person. A face in the distance becomes an indistinct patch of darkness. Something moving at the edge of the picture may be impossible to identify.
The audience is left to fill in the blanks.
This is especially effective in footage supposedly recorded by an ordinary person rather than a professional filmmaker.
Someone points a camcorder into a dark basement. The autofocus struggles. The image becomes noisy. The camera shakes.
Then something moves.
You can't tell what it is, but you know you don't want to meet it.
The beauty of this approach is that the creature doesn't need elaborate makeup, expensive animation, or 47 rows of teeth. Sometimes the most frightening monster is the one you cannot properly see.
Besides, if you reveal your monster too clearly, somebody will inevitably pause the movie, zoom in, and post a screenshot online with the caption: "Looks like a guy in a rubber suit."
The horror is gone. The internet has won.