Dead Silence (2007)
What's the one thing creepier than a ventriloquist dummy? A whole room full of them. What's creepier than that? Discovering that one of them might be responsible for a string of gruesome murders. And what's creepier still? Finding out that the filmmakers behind Saw decided to build an entire horror movie around the idea that dolls are absolutely, positively not to be trusted. Welcome to Dead Silence, where the only thing worse than a bad ventriloquist is a ventriloquist who doesn't need a living partner.
Directed by James Wan and released in 2007, this supernatural horror film follows Jamie Ashen, a man who returns to his hometown after his wife is brutally murdered. His investigation leads him to the legend of Mary Shaw, a murdered ventriloquist whose ghost is said to haunt the town and punish anyone who screams in her presence. Naturally, this means Jamie must investigate a creepy old theatre, a collection of unsettling puppets, and a family history that makes his in-laws look positively normal.
Starring Ryan Kwanten, Amber Valletta, and Donnie Wahlberg, Dead Silence leans heavily into gothic atmosphere, elaborate set design, and the sort of sinister dolls that make you want to lock every toy cupboard in the house. It also features a memorable twist, because apparently the filmmakers weren't satisfied with simply giving an entire generation of viewers a reason to cover their childhood toys with blankets.
Although it arrived during the wave of supernatural horror that followed Saw, Dead Silence takes a very different approach, trading industrial traps for old-fashioned ghost stories and theatrical scares. But does its combination of creepy puppets and gothic mystery still work, or has time turned its nightmares into little more than wooden performances?
Frightfully Forgotten pulls back the curtain on this ventriloquist-themed nightmare to see whether Dead Silence deserves another round of applause — provided nobody in the audience opens their mouth.
Watch the Frightfully Forgotten review below!